Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Comparing Malcom X and Sherman Alexie


Sherman Alexie and Malcom X were both very self-motivated to learn about literacy and become literate themselves.  Alexie mentions in his article, “Superman and Me” that his love of reading and love of books sprouted from his admiration of his father who loved books too.  Malcom X’s quest for literacy came when he was behind bars and no longer wanted to be just a fast-talking hustler.  He mentions in his piece, “Learning to Read” that he wanted to be able to portray his feelings correctly in letters, and that he admired another inmate whose knowledge made him extremely respected and in–control of situations.
Both authors were sort of similar in terms of socioeconomic status at the times when they speak about seeking out literacy.  Both had little money, Alexie was a child on an Indian Reservation. Malcom  X was a prisoner behind bars.  Both were minorities, Malcom X was an African American, Sherman Alexie was a Native American.  They differed quite a bit in their resources, sponsors, and access. For Sherman Alexie, his father was a huge sponsor who was always bringing books home for him to read. Also, he had access to different things through the school and the community such as flyers and comic books as he describes in his piece. Malcom X’s situation was different from that.  He was an inmate in a prison with no constant connection to the outside community. He was able to read books that were provided by the prison but the prison itself is not a place I would consider to be a huge sponsor. 

5 comments:

  1. it is nice that Malcom X realized the power that goes along with literacy. not only does one gain power when they are able to read, they gain respect. it is easy to see that Malcom X gained that respect after learning to read and becoming a respectable member of society

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is interesting to look at the similiarities and differences between Sherman Alexie and Malcolm X. They both have admirable stories and their hunger for knowledge is something very rare these days and can be looked at as a great attribute. I think both of these men should be looked up to as heros not only by people of their own minority groups, but by all Americans.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I like how you talked about how both authors were in seriously different situations, yet were in similar socioeconomic statuses at the same time because thats basically what i said in my post as well. Self motivation is pretty hard to come by; both stories are very impressive and as we can now see the arduous self teaching has definitely paid off.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Both authors were in quite similar socioeconomic statuses. They were both poor, but even with this I found it very interesting that Sherman Alexie was able to teach himself to read at such a young age.

    ReplyDelete